Back to Tsunami Main Page

ENVIRONMENTAL AND GEOGRAPHICAL EFFECTS:


1. Study warns against impact of coastal tourism, The New Indian Express dated 28/12/04
Apparently innocuous activities, especially tourism, are inflicting serious ecological and social damage.

2. Immense damage to ecology feared in Andamans , The Hindu dated 3/1/05
Though it is too premature to say anything unless a proper assessment is made, preliminary reports received by us suggest that the damage could be immense

3. `Tsunami has not affected marine life', Deccan Herald dated 3/1/05.

The mystery of the sea or ocean was that it would never retain any dead bodies or carcasses for more than 24 hours, and would automatically spew them and wash them ashore. But in the tsunami-hit areas, nothing of the sort was noticed and therefore, it could be presumed that the marine life had not suffered damage.

4. Coral reefs in the Andamans suffer extensive damage, Deccan Herald dated 5/1/05

The coral reefs along the coast of the Andaman Islands are about 1000 years old and could not withstand the tsunami.

5. Ecological resources damaged in tsunami-hit regions:Report, Business Line dated 8/1/05
The Government has said that the preliminary assessment of the tsunami-affected regions in the country indicate severe damage to some "significant ecological resources".
6. 'Earth still ringing like a bell after Indian Ocean quake', The New Indian Express dated 10/1/05

Australian National University scientists said hyper-sensitive gravity measuring equipment showed minute reverberations may continue for weeks.

7. Marine biologists still in the dark, The Hindu dated 12/1/05

Ocean scientists and marine biologists are completely in the dark whether the tsunami has created any change in deep-water marine life and in the chemical and physical composition of the sea.


8. Govt to assess ecological and geomorphological damage, uniindia.com dated 14/1/05

This assessment would be completed by March 6.


top


1. Study warns against impact of coastal tourism, The New Indian Express dated 28/12/04

THIRUVANANTHAPURAM: The killer waves have exposed the fragility of the coastal areas. But it does not require a tsunami to wreak massive destruction in these areas.

Apparently innocuous activities, especially tourism, are inflicting serious ecological and social damage.

A study, `Adversities of coastal tourism - A quantitative approach', which was presented here on Monday, said that the coastal tourism had environmental, ecological, social and cultural implications. The study was presented by commerce lecturer Jacob Thomas as part of an International Conference on Tourism organised by the Kerala University Department of Commerce and Alumni Association at the Mascot Hotel.

The study noted that the major changes caused by the wayward ways of coastal tourism were the changes in the land use pattern and destruction of marine resources. The former had scuttled the ecological balance and the latter had badly affected the composition of food chain in the ecology. The unbridled growth of tourism had also led to floods and the sedimentation in the natural harbours.

It said that the `resort development' trend was the main culprit. The mushrooming of resorts along the coastal areas had led to the destruction of shorebird habitats, depletion of fisheries, erosion of swimming beaches, poisoning of coral reefs and pollution of harbours. The conversion of mangrove wetlands for construction purposes had changed the environment.

The study said that the coastal regions, the community in particular, had to pay the price for the leisure activities of tourists. Motor boating and yachting caused physical damage from anchorings and boat groundings. Scuba diving caused breakage and lesions. The collection of shells, lobsters, conch and coral threatened the survival of rare species.

The preferences of tourists too had their adverse effects. The study said the Westerners were always on the lookout for under-developed coastal strips. As a result, more and more virgin beaches and coastal regions were falling prey to the rapaciousness of tourism, it said.

top

2. Immense damage to ecology feared in Andamans , The Hindu dated 3/1/05
By Aarti Dhar
NEW DELHI, JAN. 2. As the world focuses its attention on the lives and property devastated by the tsunami waves, environmentalists fear that the damage to the ecology will be no less, particularly in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands.
``Though it is too premature to say anything unless a proper assessment is made, preliminary reports received by us suggest that the damage could be immense,'' says environmental activist and travel writer Shorobindo Dey.
`Salination'
Besides extensively damaging the flora and fauna of this ecologically-fragile region, experts fear that the entire soil of the islands could have been salinated. If `salination' is only on the upper layers, desalination would be easier but if the water has percolated deep, it would have left the soil unfit for any kind of vegetation.
As the beaches are also reported to have been washed away and the `sea-walls' — walls made to check erosion of beaches — pulled down, it is possible that a large area of the islands could have been ``eaten into'' by the sea. Researches over the years had shown that the area of the islands was gradually decreasing which prompted the Supreme Court to increase the forest cover of the islands to 4,000 hectares. This was being done by jatropha and bamboo cultivation as the climatic and soil conditions were best suited for the growth of these two plantations. Now, if the soil has a high salt content, there would hardly be any vegetation.
Mangroves, coral reefs
``The tidal waves would have extensively damaged the mangroves and coral reefs,'' says Anwar Ahmed of the Island Development Authority. Mangroves are responsible for holding the beaches and if these are damaged, then the threat of erosion is greater, he points out. Mr. Ahmed, however, believes that the Jarawa Forest Reserve will be safe since it is on a higher altitude.
On the other hand, Mr. Dey expresses concern over the fate of some rare species of crocodiles and leather-back turtles. ``This happens to be the nesting season for at least one of the endangered leather-back species of turtles that come on the Greater and Little Nicobar beaches. The nesting peaks between December and January. One cannot say what happened to them,'' he says, fearing the worst.
Both Mr. Dey and Mr. Anwar are equally concerned about the fate of the aboriginal tribes on the islands. ``Perhaps, it is nature's way of telling people to be more environment-sensitive,'' feels Mr. Dey.

* Earthquakes below or near ocean floors, landslides, volcanic eruptions, explosions, the impact of cosmic bodies like meteorites can cause tsunamis

* The earthquake off the Indonesian coast heaved the ocean floor to create waves travelling at 750-800 km/hr in all directions

* A tsunami approaches shallow waters off the shore with tremendous energy

* As its coastline speed slows to 50-60 km/hr in shallow waters its height grows into a wall of water 10 to 30 m high

* Tsunamis, or tidal waves can strike 10-20 minutes apart.

top


3. `Tsunami has not affected marine life', Deccan Herald dated 3/1/05.
By A.V. Ragunathan
CUDDALORE, JAN. 2. Preliminary studies have shown that the tsunami has wrought havoc only on terrestrial areas and not in the deep sea. All along the eastern coast, there is no report of washing ashore of marine organisms, including fish, dolphins, sharks or whales, according to T. Balasubramanian, Director, Centre for Advanced Study in Marine Biology, Portonovo.
Mr. Balasubramanian told The Hindu that it was surprising to note that even at the points where the shoals of fish were found in abundance, no loss could be noticed. Nor was there any abnormal migration of sea animals on the surface, and this indicated that in the bowels of the sea, the marine life was safe and active.
The mystery of the sea or ocean was that it would never retain any dead bodies or carcasses for more than 24 hours, and would automatically spew them and wash them ashore. But in the tsunami-hit areas, nothing of the sort was noticed and therefore, it could be presumed that the marine life had not suffered damage.
Asked whether it would be safe to consume sea fish and lobsters, Mr. Balasubramanian said there would be no harm, because on-land viruses and bacteria would not survive in saline water. Tere existed a natural immune system in the ocean.
On whether the marine animals could sense an impending disaster, he said no specific study had been done so far, but going by the popular perception in the case of birds and animals, it could be presumed that whenever there was disturbance in the seabed or in the flow of sea currents, the marine animals would become alert and swim to safer places.
Boost to fish population
The Director noted that there was a silver lining in the disaster too, as it would help in the prolific propagation of marine life. Mr. Balasubramanian said when the sea was churned, the nutrient-rich bottom soil got spread over a wider area, thus becoming a good breeding ground for marine animals.
Therefore, in the aftermath of tsunami, there was a possibility of fish population going up. It was also a blessing in disguise for his Centre, as the huge waves had opened up the Vellar estuary to a length of 50 ft, facilitating free movement of marine life in and around Portonovo.

top

4. Coral reefs in the Andamans suffer extensive damage, Deccan Herald dated 5/1/05

The coral reefs along the coast of the Andaman islands are about 1000 years old and could not withstand the tsunami.

BY PRASANTA PAUL, Deccan Herald, KOLKATA:
Scientists belonging to the Zoological Survey of India engaged in the task of researching the effect of the tsunami on the seabed near the shore say that a large portion of the coral reefs of the Andamans failed to survive the impact of the tsunami while the rest might have suffered extensive damages.

Besides being perpetual soil binders, coral reefs were a major tourist attraction. Scuba diving in the ocean to get a closer glimpse of the coral reef was a popular sport.

Marine biologists have appealed to the administration to issue an immediate order banning tourists from any sort of exploration in the area housing the coral reefs, as it has been observed from satellite pictures that more than 45 per cent of the reef has been destroyed.

And the surviving reefs have suffered extensive damage from the impact of the debris that was washed into the sea from the islands. Scientists say that the it will take 700 to 800 years for the soft coral to rejuvenate.

According to ZSI joint director of Andamans Mr D K Shastri, a full ZSI team will be pressed into service for a detailed under sea investigation once the aid workers and the integrated Relief Command conclude their task of rehabilitation. A team of trained ZSI divers will be dispatched to the affected region to videograph the existing structure of coral reef from several angles to facilitate a detailed study.
Apparently, the strong, “stonified” reef stood a chance of withstanding the shock.

Earlier studies of the reef in the Andamans have revealed that the coral reefs are of the fringing type, lying just off the coastline. This is why marine biologists feel that chances of survival of the coastal reef are bleak.

A senior scientist working with the Jadavpur University's School of Oceanographic & Environmental Studies which has been monitoring damage to the reef, feels that physical verification of the damage could lead to a worse discovery.

“It could be more than what the satellite pictures have shown,” he said. Unlike other parts of the world where coral reefs are nearly million years old and extremely sturdy, the reefs off the islands along the coast of Andamans, are relatively new (about one thousand years old) and of the estimated 316 species that the archipelago has to offer, the unique ones could have become extinct, because of the tsunami waves.

top


5. Ecological resources damaged in tsunami-hit regions: Report, Business Line dated 8/1/05
Our Bureau
New Delhi , Jan. 7
THE Government has said that the preliminary assessment of the tsunami-affected regions in the country indicate severe damage to some "significant ecological resources".
They include mangroves, corals, forests, coastal wetlands, sand dunes, rock formations, biodiversity and groundwater. "Some of the damage to ecological assets may impact livelihood of the people," informed an official release.
This was indicated at a meeting of experts from various institutions under the chairmanship of the Secretary, Ministry of Environment and Forests, Dr Prodipto Ghosh, here. The meeting was convened to assess the damage to ecological assets in the wake of tsunami.
The evaluation of ecological damages would be undertaken in two stages. "In the first stage, rapid assessment based on pre-tsunami and post-tsunami satellite images of affected regions and available data would be undertaken by the institutions concerned to identify the damage to ecological assets, important for livelihood and habitations, which suffered significant long-term damage, but which are amenable to restoration," informed a statement.
Preliminary assessment report would be submitted within two months. On the basis of preliminary assessment, a detailed evaluation of the ecological damage would be made, in the second stage, for the identified ecological resources to develop an action plan for their restoration.
The institutions which would undertake the assessment in the first stage, include the Institute for Ocean Management, Anna University, Chennai; the Centre for Advanced Studies in Marine Biology, Annamalai University, Chidambaram; Space Application Centre, Ahmedabad; the Centre for Earth Science Studies, Thiruvananthapuram; the Forest Survey of India; the Zoological Survey of India; Botanical Survey of India; Central Water Commission; Coast Guards; and the Central Pollution Control Board.

top

6. 'Earth still ringing like a bell after Indian Ocean quake', The New Indian Express dated 10/1/05
AFP
SYDNEY: Much of the Earth was still "ringing like a bell" two weeks after the December 26 earthquake that unleashed devastating tsunamis around the Indian Ocean, Australian scientists said on Sunday.

Australian National University scientists said hyper-sensitive gravity measuring equipment showed minute reverberations may continue for weeks.

Herb McQueen, from the university's Earth Sciences Research School, said the equipment at the Mount Stromlo observatory in Canberra showed the planet was "ringing like a bell" which had been forcefully struck.

He said the movement was imperceptible to all but the most sensitive equipment.

"(It) corresponds to about a millimetre of vertical motion of the earth," he said. "The early signals were much stronger."

McQueen said it was a rare seismic event, picked up by the observatory's machines, which are normally used to map the structure of the planet's interior.

Immediately after quake, which measured 9.0 on the Richter scale, US geophysicists said it made the Earth wobble on its axis and permanently altered the map of Asia by moving some small islands up to 20 metres.

top

7. Marine biologists still in the dark, The Hindu dated 12/1/05
CHENNAI: Each time a cyclone hit, the successive year had shown an increase in fish production. But what has the tsunami done to the sea?

Ocean scientists and marine biologists are completely in the dark whether the tsunami has created any change in deep-water marine life and in the chemical and physical composition of the sea. However, investigation is on.

Fishery and Oceanographic Research vessels of the Department of Ocean Development–Sagar Sampada and Sagar Kanya–, research vessels of the Fisheries Survey of India and other agencies are already doing rounds of the Indian Ocean. ‘‘Has the tsunami brought any qualitative change in the sea? Has the churning of the sea brought out nutrients settled in the bottom? These are some of the main questions that will be investigated,’’ said a senior official at the Department of Ocean Development.

The Sagar Kanya that is currently at the lowermost portion of the South of Chennai will take sonar images and also collect samples to understand changes in the ‘‘chemical oceanography.’’ The Sagar Sampada is equipped to study biological material. The scientists from various agencies across the nation are also busily testing mud and water samples to study changes in the constituency.

The scientists are baffled as large-scale mortality of marine-life or carcasses of fish coming to the shore have been almost unreported after the tsunami.‘‘There have been no carcasses washed ashore. But it has to be investigated if there has been any mortality in the deep-waters,’’ the officer said.The nutrient level in the sea normally increases after a cyclone as there is increased water flow into the sea.

UNPRECEDENTED ACTIVITY: In October 2004, a field officer at Cuddalore working for the Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute had reported that a species of fish found only in deep-waters had been caught by fishermen in shallow waters and this could be a warning for the onset of a natural calamity. The ‘Red Bait’ or ‘Aranaival’ fish had started coming out of its ‘home’. ‘‘The officer said that the fish normally changed its inhabitation only when the seas experienced turbulence, which had been reported before in 1977, 1979, 1987 and 1996,’’ said Mohammed Qasim, scientist-in-charge of the (CMFRI).

The field scientist had said in the report that it was to be noted that in all these years some sort of natural calamity had struck, including a ‘phsunami’ (tsunami) in Japan and cyclones in the Bay of Bengal.

top

8. Govt to assess ecological and geomorphological damage, uniindia.com dated 14/1/05

New Delhi, Jan 14 (UNI) The Central Government has decided to carry out assessment of the ecological and geomorphological damage caused by the tsunami in various areas of the country.

The giant killer waves not only caused destruction of life and property but also serious damage to the coastal ecological resources, Ministry of Environment and Forests sources said today.

Besides, the coastal communities were directly or indirectly dependent upon these coastal resources for their livelihood, they added.

''A high level meeting was held on January 5 to take stock of the damage caused to the ecological and geomophological features in the coastal and marine areas. It was decided that the assessment of the damages caused by the tsunami would be carried out in two phases.'' In the first phase, a rapid assessment based on satellite imageries would be done by scientific institutions such as Space Application Centre, Ahmedabad, Institute for Ocean Management, Chennai, Centre for Earth Science Studies, Trivandrum, Centre for Advance Marine Studies Chidambaram, Zoological Survey of India, Botanical Survey of India and Forest Survey of India.

This assessment would be completed by March 6, sources said.

Based on the rapid assessment studies, a detailed programme would be worked out for evaluation of coastal ecological resources, which were important for livelihood and/or coastal protection, and which have suffered long-term damage and the ways the damage could be remedied, they added.

''This detailed valuation will lead to an Action Plan for restoration of the ecological and geomorphological features.'' Apart from this, the ministry had also initiated several proactive measures in protecting the coastal areas by programmes such as mangrove development schemes, coral reefs protection measures and shelter bed plantation along the coastal areas, sources said.

''About 35 potential mangrove plantation areas and four coral reef areas have been identified for conservation and management and financial assistance of Rs 4.5 crores annually was being provided to the concerned State Governments.'' During the year 2002-2003 an area of about 3,500 was afforested with mangroves, they added.

top